Republican Senator Rand Paul opposed to Trump’s Mass Deportation Plan

Jim Beam

The Gold Standard in fact checking
Reaction score
-76
Location
New Jersey
Mass and indiscriminate deportation is a mistake.

I am 100% for ditching the dogshit and criminal element of that population, but there must be a provision for productive people who have been here for years contributing to our society

and unlike you scum on the left that sees such undocumented persons as a means to contribute without personal benefit to YOUR social security I believe they should be eligible to collect on a program they've paid into provided they can probe they've paid into it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: X

The Prowler

Site Supporter
Reaction score
3,720
Location
Canada
Trump needs to create a new private police force.



With a snazzy logo....

200px-Flag_of_the_Schutzstaffel.svg.png
 

Seamajor

Site Supporter
Reaction score
7,484
Mass and indiscriminate deportation is a mistake.

I am 100% for ditching the dogshit and criminal element of that population, but there must be a provision for productive people who have been here for years contributing to our society

and unlike you scum on the left that sees such undocumented persons as a means to contribute without personal benefit to YOUR social security I believe they should be eligible to collect on a program they've paid into provided they can probe they've paid into it.
Do you contribute to SS?
 
OP
OP
Joe

Joe

Reaction score
3,768
Mass and indiscriminate deportation is a mistake.

I am 100% for ditching the dogshit and criminal element of that population, but there must be a provision for productive people who have been here for years contributing to our society

and unlike you scum on the left that sees such undocumented persons as a means to contribute without personal benefit to YOUR social security I believe they should be eligible to collect on a program they've paid into provided they can probe they've paid into it.

Thats why I thought it best to legalize & to provide the law abiding tax paying productive migrants with 1 year renewable non immigrant ‘X’ visas for low skilled labor.

Same time they wouldnt be allowed to upgrade these visas towards a path to citizenship. Nor would they be eligible for any benefits like social security or unemployment benefits. And they couldnt take high paying professional or skilled trades jobs away from US citizens. Theyd be restricted to low skilled labor such as domestics laborers or farmhands. If they want to send their children to schools or access the public health system they'd be required to pay international fees. In other words theyd be paying into the system but couldnt get anything out of it.

This is a similar in concept to non immigrant Free Trade visas for Canadian or Mexican professional/technical workers but for laborers or farmhands.

I agree that these migrants should be regulated & the US should be able to deport those who arent obeying the law.

For those who want citizenship badly enough make them serve in a US equivalent of the French Foreign legion for a minimum of 10 years.
 
OP
OP
Joe

Joe

Reaction score
3,768
Perhaps....in camps....
Well I know you're a dork Lex @The Prowler and you can't respond with anything more then three word grunts.

But how do you suggest Trump manage deportations or limiting migrations without major disruptions in the US Economy?

It isn't just Democrats/Leftists who are calling out Trump, it's conservative minded pro-Business owners.

And they voted for Trump

Because mass deportations would translate into the loss of an affordable labor supply.

So the best compromise would be deporting the criminal elements and retaining productive low skilled low wage workers by providing them with renewable 1 year visas.

Currently the US doesn't appear to have a designation for low skilled workers.
But they are needed to keep the costs of certain products down such as produce, fruit/vegetables.
 

The Prowler

Site Supporter
Reaction score
3,720
Location
Canada
Well I know you're a dork Lex @The Prowler and you can't respond with anything more then three word grunts.

But how do you suggest Trump manage deportations or limiting migrations without major disruptions in the US Economy?

It isn't just Democrats/Leftists who are calling out Trump, it's conservative minded pro-Business owners.

And they voted for Trump

Because mass deportations would translate into the loss of an affordable labor supply.

So the best compromise would be deporting the criminal elements and retaining productive low skilled low wage workers by providing them with renewable 1 year visas.

Currently the US doesn't appear to have a designation for low skilled workers.
But they are needed to keep the costs of certain products down such as produce, fruit/vegetables.

Slavery?

Good idea.
 
OP
OP
Joe

Joe

Reaction score
3,768
Slavery?

Good idea.
Well in that case, why don't we make you into a slave, Lex @The Prowler ?

Take away your home & your Corvette, sell it at auction for pennies on the dollar.

That'd be nice. Give you a taste of your own medicine.

Your types like tough draconian measures as long as it's for somebody else who pays the price & not you.
 

The Prowler

Site Supporter
Reaction score
3,720
Location
Canada
Well in that case, why don't we make you into a slave, Lex @The Prowler ?

Take away your home & your Corvette, sell it at auction for pennies on the dollar.

That'd be nice. Give you a taste of your own medicine.

Your types like tough draconian measures as long as it's for somebody else who pays the price & not you.

You are the one promoting the idea of slavery, you stooge.
 
OP
OP
Joe

Joe

Reaction score
3,768
You are the one promoting the idea of slavery, you stooge.

There's already a lot of prison labor in the US where inmates work for 13 cents an hour you dope, Lex @The Prowler



It's the kind your hero Trump and his party are pushing by building more prisons, Lex.

But being the ignorant sod you are, you wouldn't know or are aware of that.

So whether you realize it or not, you already support Slave Labor because you admire politicians who push and implement it.
 

The Prowler

Site Supporter
Reaction score
3,720
Location
Canada
There's already a lot of prison labor in the US where inmates work for 13 cents an hour you dope, Lex @The Prowler



It's the kind your hero Trump and his party are pushing by building more prisons, Lex.

But being the ignorant sod you are, you wouldn't know or are aware of that.

So whether you realize it or not, you already support Slave Labor because you admire politicians who push and implement it.


Senile @Joe is giddy that him and I see eye-to-eye on the whole "Slavery is Good!!" topic.