I challenge MAGA posters to stop using this fallacy

[Lily]

Nope! That land is ISRAEL for thousands of yeers!!

What do you think Exodus in the Bible is about?

They were in Egypt, you know that? There is a reason that a Jewish diaspora is spoken of...derp

 

[Weeg]

What do you think Exodus in the Bible is about?

They were in Egypt, you know that? There is a reason that a Jewish diaspora is spoken of...derp

The name "Israel" first appears in the Hebrew Bible as the name given by God to the patriarch Jacob (Genesis 32:28). Deriving from the name "Israel", other designations that came to be associated with the Jewish people have included the "Children of Israel" or "Israelite".

 

[Weeg]

No

INCORRECT The name "Israel" first appears in the Hebrew Bible as the name given by God to the patriarch Jacob (Genesis 32:28). Deriving from the name "Israel", other designations that came to be associated with the Jewish people have included the "Children of Israel" or "Israelite".

 

[Lily]

The name "Israel" first appears in the Hebrew Bible as the name given by God to the patriarch Jacob (Genesis 32:28). Deriving from the name "Israel", other designations that came to be associated with the Jewish people have included the "Children of Israel" or "Israelite".

Countries aren't based on religious text.

 

[Weeg]

Countries aren't based on religious text.

Lily yoo are wrong

 

[Lily]

Lily yoo are wrong

No, I'm not.

You are clueless.

 

[X]

Libs hate facts

Contards make up their own, repeat them so many times they’re obviously true BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

 

[Weeg]

No, I'm not.

You are clueless.

yes yoo are

 

[The Atomic Punk]

What do you think Exodus in the Bible is about?

They were in Egypt, you know that? There is a reason that a Jewish diaspora is spoken of...derp

The book of Exodus depicts the return of the Israelites back to Isreal/Caanan. They fled to Egypt due to drought and the resulting famine in Caanan. Hundreds of years later the leaders in Egypt became wary of the Israelites as their numbers grew, and a harsh rule began over them.

Ultimately the Exodus story /event occured and the Israelites were returned home to Caanan.

The diaspora you referenced occurred centuries later after the Israelites became entangled in conflicts with Assyria, the Babylonian forces and others and later Rome.

Israel is in-fact the original home to the Jews

...........Derp

 

[Mr. Wednesday]

I never said you asked me a loaded question. I said you committed the many questions fallacy, because, quite simply, your bullshit question requires many answers, and as I said you in my earlier post, you're not looking for an answer at all. You are simply trying to get me to say something that you will then refute, so I am not going to waste my time with your incorrigible bullshit anymore.

IOW: "Fuck, my bullshit excuse didn't fool him, now I'm gonna run away like a little bitch."

Good.

 

[Lily]

The book of Exodus depicts the return of the Israelites back to Isreal/Caanan. They fled to Egypt due to drought and the resulting famine in Caanan. Hundreds of years later the leaders in Egypt became wary of the Israelites as their numbers grew, and a harsh rule began over them.

Ultimately the Exodus story /event occured and the Israelites were returned home to Caanan.

The diaspora you referenced occurred centuries later after the Israelites became entangled in conflicts with Assyria, the Babylonian forces and others and later Rome.

Israel is in-fact the original home to the Jews

...........Derp

WAS

they left it willingly

 

[The Atomic Punk]

WAS

they left it willingly

And went back.........and conquered it........

"They were in Egypt, you know".........yes, but they were in Caanan first.......just like you were told.

 

[The Atomic Punk]

I have answered, many times over. Not my fault I didn't give the answer you were trolling for.

No one was trolling.......well not trolling you and the other Bedwetters.

The folks trolling are the ones making claims about concequences Due to the election.........without stating exactly what they are, or........how specifically how President Trump will cause them.

We just want to know specifically how we will be affected........enlighten us

 

[Lily]

And went back.........and conquered it........

"They were in Egypt, you know".........yes, but they were in Caanan first.......just like you were told.

And they were conquered by the Romans and lost it again

Let me know when you're ready to give land back to indigenous Americans, they were here first and settled it permanently.

 

[The Atomic Punk]

Countries aren't based on religious text.

What do you think Exodus in the Bible is about?

They were in Egypt, you know that? There is a reason that a Jewish diaspora is spoken of...derp

This Lily ..........is unfortunately the most accurate depiction of how ignorant you are.

On one hand you dispute that the Bible contains historical record, and then on the very same page you use a book of the Bible to explain your point about the timeline of the Jews including the subsequent diaspora.

You are truely one to be pitied the most among all the Bedwetters.

 

[Mr. Wednesday]

And they were conquered by the Romans and lost it again

Let me know when you're ready to give land back to indigenous Americans, they were here first and settled it permanently.

Then let them try to reconquer it.

 

[The Atomic Punk]

Let me know when you're ready to give land back to indigenous Americans, they were here first and settled it permanently.

Did they really settle it permanently?

I ask this because they are not the leaders of this country........the land in North America referred to as the United States.

So here is the real parallel to the Israelis.........the Native Americans were exiled as well, as were the Jews with the diaspora you note above.......you recall the "trail of tears" no.

Then.........years later........restoration.......and I did not have to be ready for it........it had already happened.

It is evident in every state where tribes have been given back land and given funding to build upon.

Again this is how ignorant you are........you just provided the perfect example and argument for the restoration of Israel in the early 20th Century.

The casual reader and others will ask themselves.....will it accept this comparison, or flail with more misaligned and fallicious arguments?

Let's see!

 

[Lily]

Did they really settle it permanently?

Yes, they did.

 

[Lily]

This Lily ..........is unfortunately the most accurate depiction of how ignorant you are.

On one hand you dispute that the Bible contains historical record, and then on the very same page you use a book of the Bible to explain your point about the timeline of the Jews including the subsequent diaspora.

You are truely one to be pitied the most among all the Bedwetters.

You have reading comprehension problems that go along with your poor writing skills.

 

[The Prowler]

Yes, they did.

That is why we all live in teepees.

 

[The Prowler]

On one hand you dispute that the Bible contains historical record, and then on the very same page you use a book of the Bible to explain your point about the timeline of the Jews including the subsequent diaspora.

Inconsistency is her middle name.


Lily Inconsistency The Fat One.

 

[Lily]

That is why we all live in teepees.

The facts are clear. Native Americans were the first permanent settlers of the Americas.

I didn't say that they were the last. You can't read AND understand though, Baldy.

 

[The Atomic Punk]

You have reading comprehension problems that go along with your poor writing skills.

So tell us……..and this is not to complex question at all.
Other than trolling the participants in the discussion, and misleading the casual reader……explain how my interpretation is incorrect.

We will break it down like this.
1) A member cited scripture to indicate that Israel was the original occupier of Canaan ( before being in Egypt)

2) You cited Exodus as evidence of Israel not being original occupants (or at least not the continuous occupants of Canaan) and the scattering of Jews later in history.

Explain to us our error in “reading comprehension”
This ought to be easy…..even for a dolt like you as you “know” exactly what you were saying.
The ball is in your court……..enlighten us.

TAP

 

[The Atomic Punk]

Yes, they did.

Then explain why we need to feel sorry or “payback” anything to them.
Are they in control now?

They settled in America ……….just as surely the Jews did in Canaan.
Thanks for proving my point……….again you are not very good at this debate thing are you.

 

[Lily]

Then explain why we need to feel sorry or “payback” anything to them.
Are they in control now?

They settled in America ……….just as surely the Jews did in Canaan.
Thanks for proving my point……….again you are not very good at this debate thing are you.

You're inconsistent.

It's too bad you're not sharp enough to see it.

I never said we need to feel sorry or need to payback anyone. You think debate is making shit up I supposedly said, and arguing the very point you made up.

You're an utter moron.

 

[The Atomic Punk]

Let me know when you're ready to give land back to indigenous Americans, they were here first and settled it permanently.

I never said we need to feel sorry or need to payback anyone

Again.......this is how ignorant you are.......you conflate the discussion by bringing up something you feel is related to the discussion, and then deny the real comparison or issue at hand whether you realize it or not

You.....Fat Head Lily brought up the concept of giving anything back to Native Americans, as they were here first......and there could be a reason they had a right to having it back. The casual reader can see that above. You implied that I ought to be and "was I ready to" give Native American back their land .....because "they were here first".......your words......not made up by me.

Why bring that up if their being here first did not matter?............You don't seem to like the fact that you just provided the absolutely perfect analogy why the Israelis should have a claim to the land.........but you did, and on cue........you deflect.

You think debate is making shit up I supposedly said, and arguing the very point you made up.

No Fatty........I repeated your words.......and explained them to you so you could understand that you were proving the point made by others......The Jews were there first and have a right to the land, just like Native Americans.

 

[Jack]

Looks like Israel and Lebanon are about to try a ceasefire.

 

[Mr. Wednesday]

Again.......this is how ignorant you are.......you conflate the discussion by bringing up something you feel is related to the discussion, and then deny the real comparison or issue at hand whether you realize it or not

You.....Fat Head Lily brought up the concept of giving anything back to Native Americans, as they were here first......and there could be a reason they had a right to having it back. The casual reader can see that above. You implied that I ought to be and "was I ready to" give Native American back their land .....because "they were here first".......your words......not made up by me.

Why bring that up if their being here first did not matter?............You don't seem to like the fact that you just provided the absolutely perfect analogy why the Israelis should have a claim to the land.........but you did, and on cue........you deflect.


No Fatty........I repeated your words.......and explained them to you so you could understand that you were proving the point made by others......The Jews were there first and have a right to the land, just like Native Americans.

As noted earlier, it's as if she doesn't even keep track of what she herself posts.

 

[The Prowler]

Inconsistency is her middle name.

Is that PI?