Quick post to call bullshit on the bull shitters.
Facebook posts blaming Biden for insulin prices miss the mark
IF YOUR TIME IS SHORT
- The Biden administration froze a Trump executive order related to drug prices, but the action had no effect on current insulin prices, because the Trump policy had not yet taken effect. The policy was also narrowly targeted to certain low-income patients.
- Individuals who take insulin could see prices fluctuate for several reasons related to their insurance coverage and the specific medication they use. Some insured patients might face a deductible that resets at the beginning of each year, for example.
- The research director for GoodRx, a company that tracks drug prices, crunched the numbers for PolitiFact and found that insulin prices are stable.
Soon after President Joe Biden took office, social media users accused the new president of hiking insulin prices for people with diabetes.
"Insulin went from $60 to $500 with the swipe of creepy Joe's pen," one widespread
. "Insulin: Month's supply under DJT, $60. Under Biden, $328," said
.
The posts, and others like them, were flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our
.)
The posts echoed a similar statement from a Senate candidate who claimed Biden had raised the cost of insulin for some of the most vulnerable Americans. PolitiFact rated that
.
That claim hinged on the Biden administration’s decision to freeze the implementation of several federal agency rules that had not gone into effect as of Jan. 20. Among those pending rules was an insulin-related
issued by former President Donald Trump in July 2020.
But the White House’s decision to temporarily freeze the rule could not have raised the current price of insulin products because the rule had not gone into effect yet. It was set to kick in on Jan. 22, two days after the White House
its regulatory freeze. The freeze on the insulin-related rule is effective until March 22.
Moreover, the Trump rule is narrowly targeted and would not apply to most Americans.
The rule would apply to federally qualified health centers, which are government-supported clinics that help people facing financial obstacles to care and prescription drugs. Specifically, it would require those centers to pass along to patients any discounts they get on purchases of insulin and epinephrine through a
, rather than pocketing the difference.
Supporters of the rule say it would help people who struggle to pay for pricey medications, but the Health and Human Services Department
in the Federal Register that it believed the rule would have "minimal economic impact" because of its limited scope.
"Many FQHCs reported already passing their discount savings onto patients and that the rule would create an administrative burden," the American Diabetes Association said in a
.
The National Association of Community Health Centers
that "overall prices of insulin and Epipens across the country are not affected by the Trump Administration regulation or the recent action by the Biden Administration."
Why insulin prices fluctuate
are a problem for the millions of Americans who rely on the medication to manage their diabetes. The high costs have been driven largely by the business practices of manufacturers, health plans and pharmacy benefit managers, PolitiFact
.
PolitiFact messaged the two Facebook posters who said their insulin costs had jumped from $60 to $500 and $328. We did not hear back from either.
A
from GoodRx, a company that reports on drug prices, shows wide variation in the retail prices for 27 insulin products across all manufacturers and insulin types.
But over time, "insulin prices are stable," said Tori Marsh, director of GoodRx research, who
in a chart for PolitiFact.
A patient holds a vial of insulin during a news conference outside the Olde Walkersville Pharmacy on July 28, 2019, in Windsor, Ontario, where the medication is far less expensive than across the border in Detroit. (AP)
What patients pay for insulin depends on several factors, including the type of insulin product they use and the type of insurance coverage they have, if any. Both insurance plans and drug prices can change year to year.
"One possibility for those with insurance coverage is that their plan may have made changes to the insulin products they cover, or changed the preferred status of certain insulins, actions which would increase out-of-pocket costs between one year and another," said Juliette Cubanski, deputy director of the program on Medicare policy at the Kaiser Family Foundation.
Insulin costs could have also gone up for some patients because their insurance includes a deductible at the start of each new year, Cubanski said. These patients would have to pay full price for their medications until their out-of-pocket costs surpass the deductible.
"The January price increases that consumers may have seen were likely because of their deductible resetting," Marsh said.
These explanations for high prices are "just the basic facts of how insurance works, not the result of any Biden administration action," Cubanski said, adding that Biden has not changed any Trump administration policies affecting insulin beyond the regulatory freeze.
For example, a Trump administration policy created a new option under Medicare Part D where drug plans can provide enrollees insulin at a flat monthly copay. It took effect in January, and it hasn’t changed.
Our ruling
A Facebook post claimed insulin prices rose "with the swipe of (Joe Biden’s) pen."
Individuals who take insulin could have seen prices fluctuate for several reasons related to their insurance coverage and the specific medication they use. But those changes can’t be pinned on the Biden administration’s actions, experts said.
The Biden administration did temporarily freeze a directive related to one federal program, but that would not have affected current insulin prices, because the policy had not yet taken effect.
We rate these Facebook posts False.
